
Gas vs. Electric Water Heaters in Edmond, and How to Size One
Choosing between gas and electric for your Edmond house, or wondering what size to buy? Read the local facts, then call or text for a quote.
Updated Prices checked
- Oklahoma Natural Gas (ONG) and Edmond Electric rebates
- Sizing by household, not guesswork
- Price before any work starts
Water heater trouble?
Most people only think about fuel when the old heater fails. That is the best time to compare, but also the most stressful, so reading this beforehand pays off.
Who supplies gas and electricity in Edmond?
Gas comes from Oklahoma Natural Gas, and electricity from a city-owned utility for homes inside the city. Not every address with an Edmond mailing address is inside the city, and the City's own electric service map shows the neighboring town of Arcadia outside its territory.
- Gas: Oklahoma Natural Gas. Its leak line is 800-458-4251, and the company says to leave the area, call 911, then call the line.
- Electric: Edmond Electric is municipally owned and buys power through the Oklahoma Municipal Power Authority. Its outage line is 405-216-7660.
- Check your bill: the name on it settles which utility serves your house.
A gas smell means leave first and call second. Touch no switches, and use a phone from outside.
How do operating costs compare?
Gas usually costs less to run per gallon of hot water, while electric costs less to install. Rates change, and no single comparison holds for every year, so look at your own bills rather than a rule of thumb.
Electric models, especially heat pump units, can also close the gap on efficiency. ENERGY STAR lists heat pump water heaters at a Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) of 3.3 to 4.1, a rating that replaced the older EF in 2017. Gas tankless models need a UEF of at least 0.95 to earn the label.
Want the numbers for your own house? Call or text and ask for a quote.
Which rebates help each fuel?
Each utility pays for different upgrades, so the fuel you choose can change the final price. Both programs have conditions, and both pages change over time, so confirm before you buy.
| Program | What it covers | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Edmond Electric | Replace electric, 30 to under 40 gallons | $200 |
| Edmond Electric | Replace electric, 40 gallons and up | $250 |
| Edmond Electric | Gas to electric tank | $350 |
| Edmond Electric | Gas to electric heat pump | $500 |
| Oklahoma Natural Gas | Tankless or condensing heater | $250 |
| Oklahoma Natural Gas | Electric to gas tank | $850 |
| Oklahoma Natural Gas | Electric to gas tankless | $1,100 |
Edmond Electric asks for a home energy audit first, a paid invoice within 90 days and a high-efficiency unit, and it excludes gas and tankless heaters. Oklahoma Natural Gas wants an active account and an application within 180 days. Neither program is a promise, so read the rules.
What are the pros and cons of each?
Gas heats faster and keeps working during some outages, and electric is simpler, with no venting. Here is the practical comparison.
- Gas tank: fast recovery, lower running cost, needs a flue and a gas line, and a pilot or igniter that can fail.
- Electric tank: no flue, easy to place, slower to recover, elements that wear out on hard water.
- Heat pump electric: very efficient, needs space and air around it, and costs more up front.
- Tankless gas or electric: see the tankless vs tank guide.
Hard water affects both. The City says its supply is hard, with the level varying by address, so see the hard water guide.
How do I size a tank for my household?
Match the tank to the number of people and how they use hot water. Rheem's sizing guide is a good starting point.
| Household | Typical tank size |
|---|---|
| 1 to 2 people | 30–40 gallons |
| 2 to 4 people | 40–50 gallons |
| 4 to 5 people | 50–55 gallons |
| 5 or more people | 75 gallons, or tankless |
Peak demand matters more than headcount. Two teenagers who each take long showers at the same hour need more than a couple who shower at different times. A large soaking tub or a second bathroom changes the answer.
Too small a tank means cold showers, and too large a one means paying to heat water that goes unused. A plumber can size it against your habits, so mention the busiest hour of your day.
What if I cannot tell which fuel I have?
Read the tank before you call, since the answer takes a minute. A flue pipe rising from the top and a gas line near the base mean gas, while a thick cable and square access panels mean electric.
If the label is unreadable, look at your last utility bills for a gas charge, or at the breaker panel for a double breaker marked water heater. Mention what you find when you call, and the person calling you back can work out the rest before quoting.
Can I switch fuels?
Yes, if the house is set up for it. Moving from electric to gas needs a gas line and a vent, while moving from gas to electric needs a circuit and sometimes a panel upgrade.
A fuel switch involves more than a like-for-like swap, so it costs more and takes longer. A typical tank replacement takes 1 to 3 hours. The rebates above can offset some of the extra, but only if you meet each rule.
What temperature should I set?
Set it to 120°F. The Consumer Product Safety Commission urges that setting because a scald takes about 5 seconds at 140°F and about 30 seconds at 130°F.
The City of Edmond's FAQ also calls for water at 120°F or higher to control sulfur bacteria. Both recommendations meet at 120°F, which is a good place to leave the dial unless a plumber tells you otherwise.
Does the City require a permit for a fuel switch?
Yes. The City of Edmond requires a permit to change out a hot water tank, and its fee schedule lists $20 for a water heater and $15 for a residential gas connection. The permit is normally handled by the plumber doing the work. The permit guide has the steps.
Call or text any hour for a price on gas or electric, or get your quote online.
Gas or electric, any size: call or text and get a price first.
Questions homeowners ask
Is a gas or electric water heater better for an Edmond home?
Use the fuel your house already has unless you have a reason to switch. Gas is usually cheaper to run where it is available, while electric is simpler to install and eligible for Edmond Electric rebates, so the right answer depends on your meter.
Who supplies natural gas in Edmond?
Oklahoma Natural Gas supplies natural gas in Edmond. Its gas-leak line is 800-458-4251, and the company asks you to leave the area and call 911 first if you smell gas.
What size water heater does my family need?
A common guide from Rheem is 30 to 40 gallons for 1 to 2 people, 40 to 50 for 2 to 4, 50 to 55 for 4 to 5, and 75 gallons or tankless for 5 or more. Peak use matters more than headcount alone.
Can I switch from electric to gas in Edmond?
If a gas line reaches the house, yes, and Oklahoma Natural Gas lists rebates for electric-to-gas swaps. The switch means a gas connection, venting and a City permit, so it costs more than a like-for-like replacement.
What temperature should I set the heater to?
Federal advice from the Consumer Product Safety Commission is a 120°F setting. At 140°F a scald takes about 5 seconds, and the City of Edmond's sulfur-smell advice also calls for at least 120°F.
Last updated: